Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts

Saturday, March 14, 2020

The Sorcerer's Apprentice

This is a very old tale about the unforeseen consequences of hubris, believing that partial knowledge is adequate and general ineptitude is of no importance. 

Possibly the best known version of this tale is the poem by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, written in 1797. This tells of a sorcerer’s apprentice who is meant to carry out various tasks while the sorcerer himself is temporarily absent. 

While cleaning, the apprentice becomes tired of carrying pails of water. So he uses his (limited) powers to enchant a broom to carry out the work. 

The trouble begins when the apprentice doesn’t know how to stop the broom. He tries to stop the broom by splitting it in half but the two halves now increase the speed of their activities by carrying in so much water that the room is flooded.

Fortunately the sorcerer returns and breaks the spell. 

The moral of the story is that only masters, with the requisite knowledge, should invoke powerful forces.
Goethe’s version is a possible rewrite of a very similar ancient Roman story narrated by Lucian (about 140 CE) that follows a similar theme which emphasises the power of magic or technology turning against the insufficiently wise or knowledgeable person invoking it.  
Now, in today’s world with technology of previously unimaginable power, Man’s moral and ethical capabilities to harness it for the good of the World in general is found to be wanting or so I believe. 
These old tales are worth recalling. I think particularly of the “World’s” response to the inescapable effects of changes to the climate brought about largely through the unfettered use of fossil fuels. 
The use of these fuels are supported because they are “good for the economy”, therefore are to be considered as “good” for all. Especially for the wealthy – the shareholders that invest in the companies that produce or use these fuels. 
It apparently matters not that “science” informs us all that the environment, the “world” that supports all we know, is being damaged at an ever increasing rate.
Ignore the science - it’s all about “money” you see!  
The trouble is that if the environment is damaged further, it will become increasingly difficult for life in general to exist. Only then will it become apparent that without people (and all that supports life on Earth), there will be no money, no companies to invest in and no shareholders demanding ever increasing dividends from evermore profitable companies. 
To me, it is blindingly obvious that PEOPLE and the ENVIRONMENT that supports all Life forms should be the focus of all – not money, however useful this may be in certain circumstances. 
Now, today, we have the COVID19 virus that is roiling the “economies” of all countries and killing thousand of people. The astonishing difference in the response is that “science” is apparently now paramount in informing us how to contend with this devastating outbreak.    
The blatant hypocrisy evident in this about face is extraordinary.

The “economy” is going to suffer you see! Simple.

Sunday, September 10, 2017

An interesting "Time Line".

I discovered this list of “Definitive moments in Science” in a book called “Why Us” by the science author James Le Fanu.

I have amended it with a couple of very important events – not recorded in the original list (amended 11/09/17).

1940 – I was born!
1945 - The atomic bomb used in anger, for the first and only time, dropped on Japan.
1946 – The electron microscope reveals the internal structure of the cell.
1947 – The invention of the transistor launches the Electronic Age.
1953 – Theory of the formation of the chemical elements of life by nuclear fusion
within stars.
1953 – The laboratory simulation of the “origin of life”.
1953 – James Watson and Francis Crick discover the “Double Helix” of DNA.
1955 – The first polio vaccine.
1957 – The (then) Soviet Union launches Sputnik and the epoch of planetary exploration.
1960 – The oral contraceptive first marketed.
1961 – The genetic code deciphered.
1965 – The theory of the “Big Bang” creation of the Universe confirmed by the discovery of cosmic microwave background radiation.
1967 – The first heart transplant.
1969 – US astronaut Neil Armstrong becomes first man on the moon.
1969 – James Lovelock proposes theory of a life-sustaining atmosphere.
1973 – The advent of genetic engineering.
1973 – First ever call on a mobile (cell) phone.
1973 - The invention of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of the brain.
1974 – The discovery of “Lucy”, Australopithecus afarensis, dated 4 million years ago, our earliest known humanoid ancestor.
1974 – The first Grand Unified Theory of particle physics.
1977 - The first personal computer designed for the mass market.
1977 – The first complete genetic sequence of an organism.
1979 – Voyagers I and II relay data from Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune (and they are still going – now in deep interstellar space).
1979 – The first “test tube baby”.
1980 – The asteroid impact hypothesis for the mass extinction of dinosaurs.
1984 – The discovery of  “Turkana Boy”, the first complete skeleton of Homo erectus, dated 1.5 million years ago – the precursor of us, Homo sapiens.
1984 – Confirmation of the theory of “plate tectonics” – moving “plates” forming the continents.
1987 – Formulation of the “out of Africa” hypothesis of human evolution.
1989 – Launch of the World Wide Web (the internet).
1990 – The Decade of the Brain (the “plasticity” of the brain discovered – for example).
1999 – The Hubble space telescope observes the birth of stars, for the first time, in the constellation Taurus.
2000 – The first self-balancing, transport machine – the Segway Human Transporter.
2001 – Publication of the Human Genome.
2001 – Apple’s iPod invented.
2001 – Invention of the first “bio-artificial” liver – functioning in place of a liver.
2002 – The first birth control “patch” produced.
2003 – The world’s first battery/petrol “hybrid” car produced by Toyota.
2005 – YouTube invented.
2007 – Apple’s iPhone invented.
2007 – The first “fast radio burst” from interstellar space identified.
2010 – The Neanderthal Genome project completed showing interbreeding with ancient humans.
2015 – Traces of liquid water discovered on Mars.
2016 – Gravitational waves discovered for the first time from a “black hole “ merger”.
2017 – The first Earth-like planet which may have liquid water on its surface, located “just” 21 light                                                                                                                                                                          years away.

Pretty impressive, Huh! All since I was born!! Mmmm.

Wednesday, June 15, 2016

Memories, Reminiscences and what End?

As one grows older perspectives on life seem to grow and alter with the years. As an example, I now live alone - my wife of many years has died. Does this bother me? Yes, but not as much as it might – I have always been satisfied with my own company. Do I miss her? More than I could ever explain to anyone. Have I memories? Of course I have. Do I reminisce? Yes.

All this, but there is something more, something deeper, something that is slowly approaching the forefront of my mind. It is, I suppose, more of a philosophical discussion with myself. I ask myself the questions – what is a memory, what is a reminiscence and the big one what, actually, is life? And then, what will my “end” be?

Neurologists, quantum biologists and psycho-pharmacologists all stake their claims to understanding when it comes to the brain. It has been established, beyond doubt, that neurons in different parts of the brain are activated (scanning techniques verify this) when looking at something, when listening to a sound, when thinking, remembering or problem solving. Various chemicals have been identified as “neuro-transmitters” that cross the synapses that lie between one neuron and another, which appear to be essential in the “storage” of information or interpreting what has been perceived in the environment.

BUT, and this is where I dispute the “science” of the determination that the brain is the only locus of life, thoughts and memories. For instance the question has yet to be answered – what comes first – do the thoughts and memories somehow activate the neurons in the brain, or do the neurons, by some means, create the thoughts?

AND, what is a thought, actually? What is a memory, actually? What is an emotion, actually? What is life, actually? No one knows.

So I ask myself the question, are they all just the result of chemicals in the brain, as neurologists and psycho-pharmacologists would claim? I ask the question, are they all just the  result of the activities of sub-atomic particles as quantum-biologists would claim? I ask the question, how can a chemical or chemicals in any combination, inanimate as they are, create or store a thought?  Particularly as no one knows what a thought is, actually! I ask the question, how can a chemical or chemicals in any combination, inanimate as they are, create or reflect on an emotion? Particularly as no one knows what an emotion is, actually!  I ask the question, how can a chemical or chemicals in any combination, inanimate as they are, create life? Particularly as no one knows what life is, actually!

Biologists and psycho-pharmacologists have determined the chemical constituents of a cell but no one (repeat no one) has ever come close to “creating” life in a petri dish by mixing together the known chemicals that constitute the structure of a cell.

It would appear to me that life is something above and beyond our knowledge. I have sat and held the hand of someone who is dying. I have sensed that the life force (however this is defined) has left, or withdrawn from, that person. What is it? So, again, what is it that is now absent from the body - the body that was alive and warm and is now dead and growing cold?

The cells that constituted the body of the person who has just died are identical to the cells that constituted the body of that same person the split second before they died - except that they are no longer “alive”.

I don’t suppose, or presume, that we will ever have a “scientific” answer to these fundamental questions, even though scientists try to convince us that the understanding science conveys is the only kind there is!

So I am left to my memories, reminiscences and philosophical thoughts to try and understand what will happen to me when I leave this “mortal coil”!!

I wonder if it will all end as Omar Khayyam wrote in his famous Rubaiyat?

 Quatrain 47
And if the Wine you drink, the Lip you press,
End in the Nothing all Things end in – Yes –
Then fancy while Thou art, Thou art but what
Thou shalt be – Nothing – Thou shalt not be less.

Or is there something more like this, the first verse from John Masefield’s, “A Creed”:

I held that when a person dies
His soul returns again to Earth;
Arrayed in some new flesh disguise
Another mother gives him birth.
With sturdier limbs and brighter brain
The old soul takes the roads again.


I prefer John Masefield’s version but you choose!

Thursday, May 31, 2012

Lost Symbols – the cause of many problems.


We all need and use symbols. Symbols refer to something that represents an unknowable. God, or Love, Goodness or Evil, or Infinity, or Wisdom, or Death, or Beauty, all commonly used words but we cannot “know” what they are. These are words that we use every day but are impossible to define, yet we all have some idea about the meaning (to us) of the concepts expressed by the words even though we can never have a full understanding of their meaning. When we are presented with something “Godlike” or experience something that cannot be known such as “Love”, or touched, such as “beauty”, we may have some ideas about what we are experiencing without being able to explain or define it. Hence there is a need for a symbol; something which expresses what we mean, or our understanding of the meaning.

Today there seems to be confusion over the meanings of the words Symbol and Idol.  A Symbol is something that represents a concept, an idea, something which is unknown, even unknowable; something which is imprecise. The purpose of a symbol is to communicate meaning. A good example of a symbol is the mathematical image: ∞, representing the concept of infinity – this useful symbol has crept into common usage. We need this symbol because we cannot “see” infinity; we cannot “touch” infinity; we know that (presumably) infinity exists but we cannot explain the concept of infinity – it just is.

On the other hand an idol is an image or other physical object accepted as representing a deity and to which religious worship is directed. This thing (even occasionally a person) is often regarded with blind admiration, adoration, or devotion. A religious idol is often called an icon.

In this modern day and age, however, we have been so conditioned by the allure of the exactitude provided by “science”, and our apparent never satisfied desire to categorise, to analyse everything, that we no longer believe in things we cannot see. We cannot “see” God therefore God doesn’t exist. There is nothing, therefore, above and beyond human existence and human beings  are just an agglomeration of matter –  just ‘mechanisms’– that the human body is just a watertight skin bag filled with blood, flesh and bones. When we “die” that is the end, there can be nothing else because “science” says so.

This leads us to the troubling idea that if something cannot be ‘proved’, cannot be measured, cannot dissected, cannot be ‘examined’ in a scientific manner (in a laboratory or under a microscope) it cannot exist or it cannot be true. All this may be very interesting but if we destroy or diminish the importance of symbols what are we left with? We, as human beings have been reduced to believing in pure materialism. A stark “black” or “white” – it either exists or it doesn’t. This extreme materialism has devalued symbols and with this there has been a corresponding loss of values.  The wondrous nature of “Life” in all its millions of forms is diminished and reduced to the random activities of atoms and molecules.  

We cannot see “Life” yet life exists. Anyone who has been present at the moment of death when an animal or a person dies will recognise that something that was there is no longer there; something has withdrawn and death is the result. Similarly with “Love”; this most transformative of emotions is reduced, by many people to be just a pleasurable, sensory activity; we derive pleasure without a conscience. We cannot see “goodness” so it is often transmogrified into something we can see – money. If we are feeling down we may decide to apply some “retail therapy” and spend money – thus (supposedly) making us feel “good”. If someone has a great deal of money they, personally, believe they must be good and many others certainly admire and respect them. We no longer have an understanding of what it is to be human.

The wonderful – but unseen – experiences or emotions and their symbols are now so diminished in our consciousness that we demean and cheapen Life (in whatever form) to the point that we exploit all forms of Life for monetary benefit (benefiting and in effect glorifying our “goodness”). Thus there human trafficking; there is slavery (often child slavery in “sweat shops”); there is sexual exploitation – all this when money and profits are considered more important than human beings. Money and no appreciation of “Life” lead to the exploitation of animals – cruelty in farm situations (“industrial” farms with animals confined in shed or cages) and in abattoirs. This is commerce without morality; this is a desire (which, unfortunately, we all seem share) for wealth without having to work for it.

There are many symbols that we used in the past that gave comfort and a link with what is difficult to understand and possibly unknowable. For instance we understand an image of the “grim reaper” (a dark hooded figure holding a scythe) as a symbol of death. We, possibly, might use the image of a tree as a symbol of “Life”, rooted in the earth with branches reaching heavenward – spanning, birth, life and the here-after; or possibly use the image of a seed with its ability to germinate and with its unknown potential. 

The number of symbols is almost endless.

We have now lost our belief in symbols – symbols of something greater than ourselves. We are the poorer for this loss. A new “God” has arisen symbolised by the images $ or €. 
All this is not to say that slavery and exploitation did not exist in olden times – of course they did. But then people had a choice and they were aware of the consequences of their activities (either heaven or hell). Today there is apparently no choice (it is either science or nothing) and people engaged in these questionable activities seem to be unaware of the consequences – almost as if the only crime is to be caught.

We have lost our symbols and now have science without humanity.

Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Why Fundamentalism holds people back.

Any individual, group, society or culture that claims to be the sole protector of the “truth”, be that truth Scientific, Statistical, Christian, Muslim, Communist or whatever – holds a fundamentalist view. In fact anyone with a fixed belief, is Fundamentalist. Fundamentalism constrains human innovation; fundamentalists want to revert to what the purveyors of the ideology consider a “cleaner’ more “pure” past. Or in the case of science (and my pet aversion, statistics) if it can’t be “proved” it doesn’t exist, it can’t work or else it is a figment of someone’s overactive imagination.

Fundamentalist either forget or ignore the human spirit, which cannot be constrained. The human spirit (however defined) needs to be free to seek, to strive and to find, in its own way - and not everyone is the same or wants the same things. Anyone who tries to hold back the human spirit, or attempts to direct it into one particular path is doomed to ultimate failure. To prove this point just take a look at what is happening in the Middle East and the hundreds of thousands demonstrating against the practices of financial institutions in American cities and it other cities around the world.

The possible exception here, to returning to the past, is the Scientific Fundamentalist who believes totally in the power and purity of scientific exposition and innovation – and there have been some wonderful inventions and discoveries. But the Scientific True Believer, in whatever field of science, has an absolute conviction that scientific “knowledge” is the basis for everything including Life itself. This scientific evidence, it is often claimed, can be proved statistically; that Statistical “facts” trump all else; that scientific concepts which are supported by statistical “proof” must therefore be true, and anyone who does not see this or who voices any opposition, is worthy of nothing but contempt.

Just recall the years of ridicule and isolation suffered by two Australian scientists, Robin Warren and Barry Marshall who in 1982 discovered that the main cause of stomach ulcers is the bacteria Heliobacter pylori. In their original paper, Warren and Marshall contended that most stomach ulcers and gastritis were caused by colonization with this bacterium, not by stress or spicy food as had been assumed before. They did not conform to current scientific thinking and were pilloried for their stand. Had they been scientific fundamentalist they would never have made this discovery and those suffering from stomach ulcers and medicine would have been the poorer. Stomach ulcers are now cured with a short course of antibiotics.

When the subject turns to Religious (or Political) Fundamentalism we delve into murky waters indeed. To my way of thinking religious or political fundamentalism (often considered one and the same when there is no division between “Church” and State) also holds back innovation by demanding (often on pain of death) that all people believe that they (the Leaders) alone know what is best for them – the populace – and that they (the fundamentalist leaders) are following God’s will. And generally fundamentalists of this ilk try to reduce the role of women to virtual slavery and to being totally dependent on the males in the family. Again, look at the Christian fundamentalists in America, the Jewish fundamentalists in Israel and the Islamic fundamentalists in many Muslim countries, particularly Iran and Saudi Arabia and then of course there is the basket case of North Korea.

I may be wrong (the favoured expression always used by someone who believes they are right!!), but by restricting education to learning the Koran and Sharia Law, or applying a strict interpretation of the Torah or the Bible, and by not educating women, these fundamentalists are holding back their citizens.

One needs to ask how fundamentalism, in any form, adds to the material or spiritual well-being of Mankind?